It is a commonplace to view
Correspondence Analysis (CA) as "Bourdieu's statististical
method": rightly so, since Bourdieu's work has provided an exemplary
use of CA. In fact, beyond CA, a constant concern for
Bourdieu has been to substantiate his theories
by statistical data and analyses. This
essential aspect of Bourdieu' work has not
been covered in detail so far by those who have
written about Bourdieu' theories . Hereafter are some landmarks, from
traditional statistics to Geometric Data Analysis.
First period (1960s and early 1970s): Bourdieu before Correspondence Analysis
As early as the "Algerian times" (1958-1961),
Bourdieu cooperated with statisticians of INSEE (the French
national Institute of official statistics). The collaboration
continued in the 1960s, as reflected in the contribution to Les Héritiers
(1964) by Alain Darbel, who calculated the
epoch-making "chances of access to university" for the
various social categories. The books of this period are filled
with contingency tables, often with traditional
chi-square statistics.
Second period (mid-1970s): Correspondence analysis
In the early 1970s, Bourdieu elaborated the concept of
field; and at the same time he was becoming aware
of the shortcomings of the traditional statistical tools: `` The
particular relations between a dependent variable (political opinion)
and so-called independent variables such as sex, age and
religion, tend to dissimulate the complete system of relations that
make up the true principle of the force and
form specific to the effects recorded in such and such
particular correlation." ( La Distinction , 1979, p.103).
Meanwhile, the geometric approach developed by Jean-Paul
Benzécri and his associates around Correspondence Analysis
was emerging. Encouraged by his braintrust of mathematicians, and
helped by Salah Bouhedja (a programmer trained in the
geometric methods), Bourdieu turned to the new approach to
synthetize his data and sustantiate his multidimensional
model of social space. ``I use Correspondence Analysis very much,
because I think that it is essentially a relational procedure whose
philosophy fully expresses what in my view constitutes social reality.
It is a procedure that 'thinks' in relations, as I try to do it with
the concept of field.'' (Preface of the German edition of Le Métier de Sociologue , 1991).
Third period (from the late 1970s): Multiple Correspondence Analysis
A breakthrough in Geometric Data Analysis was accomplished
when the basic algorithm of Correspondence Analysis was
applied to Individuals x Variables tables, synthetizing a
host of contingency tables by the two fundamental clouds of properties
and of individuals. This approach was used by Bourdieu and
Saint-Martin in the pioneer paper Anatomie du Goût (1976)
taken up in La Distinction (1979). More specifically, for categorized
variables, Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA) became in
France a standard method for the analysis of questionnaires.
This method was applied in Le patronat (1978), Homo
Academicus, Noblesse d'Etat, Structures sociales de
l'économie, etc. Up to now, MCA has come to be part
of all empirical work conducted along Bourdieusian
lines. In this last lecture at College de France, in 2001,
Bourdieu reiterated:
``Those who know the principles of
multiple correspondence analysis will grasp the affinities between this
method of mathematical analysis and the thinking in terms of
field. " (in Science de la science et réflexivité , p.70, 2001).
References
. Rouanet H., Ackermann W., Le Roux B. (2000) .
The geometric analysis of questionnaires: the lesson of Bourdieu's La
Distinction, Bulletin de Méthodologie Sociologique , 65,
5-15.
. Bourdieu P. (1999). Une révolution conservatrice dans
l'édition, Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales [The
last Bourdieu's empirical study]
. Hjellbrekke J., Le Roux B., Korsnes O., Lebaron
F., Rosenlund L., Rouanet H. (2007) : The Norwegian field of power,
European Societies .
. Lebaron F. ( 2006). L'enquête quantitative : recueil et analyse des données, Paris, Dunod.
Module Analyse Géométrique des données
|